Discussion:
Aint got no Arthur?
(too old to reply)
Daniel Mac an Toisich
2004-11-26 22:26:43 UTC
Permalink
It is charcteristic of Indo-european languages that many words with gn
or 'g (something) n' or 'g (something) r' are related in their
meanings deriving from some common meaning related to knowledge and/as
creation - examples being gnosis, knowledge (the g has changed to k)
genesis , genetic, generation, and so on. In Gaelic there also exists
the practice where words beginning gn are pronounced gr (as its easier
to say - and this probably explains the link between the above gn
words sometimes applying to gr sounds too)

Thats the theory here is the denouement: In gaelic a word meaning
system or order (such as a system of laws and so on) is gneitheil -
pronounced 'grail'. With reference to the above mentioned etymology
group - gnosis in particular - any views?
flink
2004-12-12 23:21:00 UTC
Permalink
Re. R & N, Greek doron Latin donum
Post by Daniel Mac an Toisich
It is charcteristic of Indo-european languages that many words with gn
or 'g (something) n' or 'g (something) r' are related in their
meanings deriving from some common meaning related to knowledge and/as
creation - examples being gnosis, knowledge (the g has changed to k)
genesis , genetic, generation, and so on. In Gaelic there also exists
the practice where words beginning gn are pronounced gr (as its easier
to say - and this probably explains the link between the above gn
words sometimes applying to gr sounds too)
Thats the theory here is the denouement: In gaelic a word meaning
system or order (such as a system of laws and so on) is gneitheil -
pronounced 'grail'. With reference to the above mentioned etymology
group - gnosis in particular - any views?
John W. Kennedy
2004-12-15 03:12:15 UTC
Permalink
Post by Daniel Mac an Toisich
It is charcteristic of Indo-european languages that many words with gn
or 'g (something) n' or 'g (something) r' are related in their
meanings deriving from some common meaning related to knowledge and/as
creation - examples being gnosis, knowledge (the g has changed to k)
genesis , genetic, generation, and so on. In Gaelic there also exists
the practice where words beginning gn are pronounced gr (as its easier
to say - and this probably explains the link between the above gn
words sometimes applying to gr sounds too)
Thats the theory here is the denouement: In gaelic a word meaning
system or order (such as a system of laws and so on) is gneitheil -
pronounced 'grail'. With reference to the above mentioned etymology
group - gnosis in particular - any views?
But how was it pronounced in the 12th century? And how were its cognates
(if they existed) pronounced in 12th-century Welsh and Breton?
--
John W. Kennedy
"Give up vows and dogmas, and fixed things, and you may grow like That.
...you may come to think a blow bad, because it hurts, and not because
it humiliates. You may come to think murder wrong, because it is
violent, and not because it is unjust."
-- G. K. Chesterton. "The Ball and the Cross"
Loading...